The Congress on Saturday (August 22, 2026) expressed concern over a Supreme Court ruling that stated that its 1978 worker-friendly interpretation of the term “industry” will not apply to fresh cases under the Industrial Relations Code of 2020, and said any move to narrow or distance the law from the broad definition of “industry” risks weakening worker safeguards.
“Justice B.V. Nagarathna’s dissent is, as always, courageous, clear and compelling.
Congress general secretary in charge of communications, Jairam Ramesh, claimed that the Modi government’s Industrial Relations Code, 2020, “significantly weakens essential safeguards for our workers”. Against this backdrop, a narrow majority of the Supreme Court, in State of Uttar Pradesh versus Jai Bir Singh delivered on August 20, 2026, has “hypothesised” a reformulation of the Triple Test laid down in its earlier landmark February 1978 verdict in the Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board versus A Rajappa case, Mr. Ramesh said on X. The importance of how “industry” is interpreted lies in the legal reality of who qualifies as a workman and, consequently, who receives the protections of labour law, he said. “In the 1978 Bangalore Water Supply case, the Supreme Court identified three elements that ordinarily characterise an industry: a systematic activity; cooperation between employer and employee; and production or distribution of goods or services calculated to satisfy human wants and wishes, excluding purely spiritual or religious services,” he said. The only exemption was core sovereign activities – such as the judiciary, law and order and defence, he said. The 2026 majority judgment narrows this approach in two important ways by requiring an activity to have a “discernible commercial character” resembling trade or business – an additional requirement not found in the earlier test; and by broadening the scope of the sovereign-function exemption, potentially placing a wider range of government activities outside the definition of “industry”, Mr. She has held that the Triple Test in the Bangalore Water Supply case required no reconsideration and, in the interest of judicial certainty, cautioned against unsettling settled law,” the Congress leader said.
