The Supreme Court has ordered every state and Union territory to constitute a special investigation team (SIT) to crack down on fraudulent motor accident compensation claims, warning insurance companies that their top management will be held accountable if suspicious claims are selectively withheld from investigators.
The court made it clear that the responsibility does not rest solely with the police.
It specifically warned insurance companies against adopting a “pick and choose” approach in referring suspicious claims to the SIT.
Odisha case gains momentum
On March 18, it brought all states and UTs, through their directors general of Police, into the proceedings, asking Odisha to place before the other states its model of investigation. It further directed insurers to act departmentally against their officials if an SIT recommendation or FIR indicates that they had facilitated a fraudulent claim. The court also directed insurers to conduct an in-house investigation wherever a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT) rejects a claim on grounds of fraud or collusion, and immediately send details of such cases to the SIT in the state where the claim was made. The court’s February order recorded that an investigation ordered in Odisha had found the vehicle was indeed involved in the accident in the case before it. But the probe also found that the same vehicle figured in four other accident cases. The revelations prompted the bench to look beyond the individual case.
“If there has been selective forwarding” of cases, the topmost management of the concerned insurance company would be held accountable, the bench said. More significantly, the Odisha authorities told the court that they had found a “wide racket” in which several stakeholders could be involved and that arrests had already taken place.
The proceedings began with a seemingly narrow dispute before the Supreme Court over whether a vehicle shown in a compensation claim was actually involved in the accident.
